Nomination Clarifications #3

[summerofhorrorexchange]

Thank you to everyone who nominated! The tagset is in the process of being finalized.

Nomination queries

• Transformers - All Media Types: Nominator(s), can you choose a more specific subfandom? If not, we will approve these under The Transformers (IDW Generation One.
  
• Fairy Tales & Related Fandoms - We have a nomination for The Frog Prince & Iron Henry. Nominator, can you clarify if these two ever appeared in the same fairy tale? If not, are you okay with it being approved under Crossover Fandom?
  
• Die schöne Müllerin - Franz Schubert (Songs) - Nominator(s), is the River a character, a setting, or a setting being used as a character?
  
• Les Misérables - All Media Types - Nominator, do you have a specific versio nof the canon you want? If not, for Anyone who dies at the barricade & any barricade survivor(s), we will approve this under the book version of the canon.
  
• The Last Unicorn - All Media Types - Nominator, do you have a specific version of the canon you want? If not, we will approve this under the 1982 film, since that seems to be the canon people usually reference with regard to the Drunk Skeleton.
  
• Tomie - All Media Types - Nominator(s), do you have a specific version of the canon in mind?
  
• The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (TV 2022): Nominator, our understanding is that Sauron and Annatar are the same character. We generally do not distinguish between different eras of a character's canon. We have already accepted Celebrimor & Sauron for Rings of Power, so this nomination will be rejected.

If any of these are tags you've nominated, please reply here or email us at summerofhorrorex at gmail to let us know how you'd like us to handle them.

Comments

[sholio]

We have a nomination for The Frog Prince & Iron Henry. Nominator, can you clarify if these two ever appeared in the same fairy tale? If not, are you okay with it being approved under Crossover Fandom?

Not the nominator, but I know that story - if I'm thinking of the same story the nominator is - and they are both characters in the same fairy tale.

[summerofhorrorexchange]

Thank you!

[wideeyedloner]

Hello! I’m the one who nominated the Drunk Skeleton. The film version is perfect!

I also messed up my character nominations when I submitted because AO3 told me the names already existed as tags, so if you wouldn’t mind adding these to the tagset I’d really appreciate it! 🙏:

Stargate:Solo characters - Teyla Emmagan, Ronon Dex, Rodney McKay, John Sheppard
Groups - The Wraith, The Ancients, Teyla Emmagan & Rodney McKay, Rodney McKay & Carson Beckett, Teyla Emmagan & Ronon Dex & Rodney McKay & John Sheppard, John Sheppard & Todd the Wraith

The Good Place: Solo characters - Tahani Al-Jamil, Chidi Anagonye, Jason Mendoza, Vicky, Glenn, Mindy St. Claire, Bad Janet, Derek

The Last Unicorn: Solo Characters - The Unicorn, The Red Bull, King Haggard, Prince Lír, Molly Grue, Schmendrick

Firefly: Solo characters - Inara Serra, Kaylee Frye, Zoë Washburne, Serenity

Adventure Time: Solo characters - Lumpy Space Princess, Tree Trunks, Princess Bubblegum, Marceline

The Last of Us: Group - The Infected

Supernatural: Solo characters - Castiel

Thank youuu 😭

[summerofhorrorexchange]

I've added these for you!

[wideeyedloner]

Thank you!! 🙏

[all_ashes]

The frog prince and iron Henry are part of the same fairy tale.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Frog_Prince

> The Frog Prince; or, Iron Henry" […] is a German fairy tale collected by the Brothers Grimm and published in 1812 in Grimm's Fairy Tales (KHM 1).

Die schöne Müllerin: it’s sort of ambiguous if the river is a character or not. The miller boy talks to it/him, and the river has a POV song at the end, but it might all just be a metaphor. It’s definitely also an actual physical river. I meant to nominate it/him as a character.

Les Mis: the request will contain a reference to the Musical, but I’m open to any version of canon.

Thank you!

[summerofhorrorexchange]

Thank you! I've approved these and added Les Mis as the musical.